Does Martha Stewart Have Soul?

>She also offered to help underprivileged women start
DOES MARTHA STEWART HAVE SOUL?their ownbusinesses. But this was in fact really a
By Stephanie Yeh and Raymond Yehmeans for her "shecould shorten her time in jail by
Whether you think Martha Stewart deserves more,offering to serve part or allof her sentence," as
less or no jailtime (more than 43% of respondents inreported in the July 19 issue of USA Today.
a recent USA Today pollthought she should spendFinally, she has asked people to stop sending gifts
more time in jail), the diva of domesticgrace is usingand to startdonating to the American Cancer Society.
her time behind bars to boost her PR value skyhigh.Considering that Stewartrecently earned a healthy $8
By going to jail early, sending out heartfelt webmillion from sales of Omnimediastock (her own
letters askingpeople to donate money to thecompany), we have to wonder whether it
American Cancer Society charityinstead of mailing herwasrealgiving or just a public show of humility.
money and gifts, and even offering toassistThe net result? Stock climbed to a four-year high this
underprivileged women start businesses, Stewart ismonth andhas climbed more than 70% since Stewart
walkinga very public "road to redemption."went behind bars.
While we can't really blame Stewart for making theLESSON: If you stumble, turn to your PR department
best of a badsituation, we have to wonder what kindfor the right
of legacy this will createfor up-and-coming"humble" moves to make. It will get you the
entrepreneurs and business leaders, not tomentionsympathy vote andkeep your stock value high.
the American public as a whole.Publicity is Always Good
Stewart's story already had enough rags-to-richesThere is no such thing as bad publicity. Stewart made
romance to makeher a top role model. Add to thatmoreheadlines as a jailbird than she ever did as the
her new seemingly humblepersona and her place as aguru of graciousliving. She has had more opportunities
societal icon is all but guaranteed.than ever to put hermessage forth, and attracted
But is what she's modeling good or bad or America?the attention of an entirely newconsumer base.
Let's break down exactly what she's demonstrating,Aside from the curiosity seekers, Americans are a
then you candecide for yourself:forgiving lot.
Arrogance is Acceptable as Long as You'reSays Rob Stearns of the business school at Arizona
SuccessfulState
Stewart is guilty of the sin common among mostUniversity and author of Winning Smart After Losing
celebrity leaders:hubris. She no doubt began believingBig,
everything her PR departmentput out. She's been"Americans will forgive high crimes and misdemeanors
labeled "power mad," "mean spirited," andandimpeachable offenses, but they won't forgive
"cruel" in the press, but the media-happy public wasarrogance." With herwell-oiled PR department and
willing toaccept her and buy her products as long aspublic acts of contrition, Stewarthas this angle
she was a wealthypublic figure.covered.
LESSON: It's perfectly acceptable to buy productsLESSON: When the media turns its spotlight on you,
from apower-mad, mean spirited, cruel leader as longuse it to youradvantage to increase your customer
as she's popularand the media likes her.base and brand recognition.
You Can Recover from Any Fall With a Show ofIn the aftermath of tragedies like Enron and Tyco,
Humblenessand in a timewhen we need ethics, values, and soul
Stewart is making a very public show of humble pie,more than ever, Stewartdemonstrates that almost
but let'stake a deeper look at the motivations behindany lack of personal and corporatevalues can be
her actions. First,she volunteered to enter prisonforgiven if your PR department is good enough.
even when she didn't have to.Stewart has shown us that success and fame are to
Sounds humble, but why did she really do it? Shebe envied andsought after, regardless. She
says it's so shecould "be back to work before thedemonstrates that being a moneyhungry "control
spring planting season" (USAfreak" behind bars is more newsworthy thananything
Today, September 15, 2004).that actually improves the human condition.